
Choosing an influencer comes down to three numbers you can check yourself before paying: where the account's audience lives, how many people actually watch its posts, and who writes the comments. Follower count is the least useful of the lot, because it is the easiest number to buy. Ask for insights screenshots from inside the creator's own account, compare them with what you see on the profile, and in Saudi Arabia confirm the licence before you sign.
Below are four signs of fake followers and bought engagement, the screens to request on Instagram and TikTok, and a thirteen-point checklist to run before any contract. We checked the sources on 18 November 2026; platform features and regulations change. The legal section is general information and is no substitute for legal advice.
What to judge an influencer on before follower count
The first test is whether the creator's audience is in the country and city where you sell, and whether a reasonable number of people watch the posts. The rest follow:
- Audience in your market. An Egyptian creator with a large Saudi following may suit a Riyadh store, and the reverse also happens. The country shows in the insights, never in the creator's accent.
- Typical views. Average the last twelve videos. Ignore the one that went viral.
- Comments asking about products. Questions about price, size or where to buy show an audience that acts on the creator's recommendations.
- Fit with your product. A cook showing a kitchen tool looks natural. A comedian showing the same tool needs a stronger idea.
- Past sponsorships. An account that promotes a different product every other day wears down its audience's trust, and may have promoted your competitor last month.
A small account with most of its audience in your city usually does more for you than a huge one spread across countries you do not ship to. If you have not yet decided whether influencers suit your business at all, start with the six questions in when influencer marketing works and how to start.
Four signs of fake followers and bought engagement
Fake followers are accounts with no real person interested in the content behind them, and they leave four traces you can check. The platforms ban buying them. Instagram's Community Guidelines ask users not to collect likes and followers artificially and forbid offering money for them. TikTok's integrity and authenticity policy says it removes fake likes and followers when it detects them, so a bought account can lose a large share of its followers overnight.
| Sign | How to check | What it may mean |
|---|---|---|
| A sudden jump in followers | Ask for the follower growth chart for the last 90 days and look for a jump with no viral video or press mention behind it | Bought followers, or a giveaway that brought in people who do not care about the content |
| Few views for the follower count | Compare average views on the last twelve videos with the follower count, then compare that ratio with other candidates of the same size | Much of the audience never sees the content |
| Generic, repeated comments | Read the comments on five posts: emoji only, the same word of praise again and again, accounts with no photo, or a language the audience does not speak | Bought engagement, or engagement pods, groups whose members comment on each other's posts |
| An audience in countries you do not sell to | Ask for the top countries and cities screen from the account's insights | The account will not reach your customers even if every follower is real |
One sign is not enough for a verdict. A video that took off explains a jump in followers, and an older account may get fewer views because its audience grew up and moved on. Ask the creator about what you noticed. A genuine account has an explanation you can match against dates.
The insights screens to request before you sign
Ask the creator for a screen recording while they open their insights and move between screens, because a still screenshot is easier to edit than a continuous video. Set the period: the last 30 days, and the last 90 days for growth.
On Instagram
Instagram Insights shows follower growth, top locations, age ranges and the times followers are most active, once the account has at least 100 followers. Viewer demographics appear when content reaches more than 100 accounts within a preset time range. Ask for the full followers screen and for the insights of at least two past sponsored posts.
On TikTok
The audience section of TikTok's Web Business Suite lists new followers, gender, age, top countries and top cities, over the last 7, 28 or 60 days. Ask for countries and cities first, since they decide what the account is worth to you.
After the post goes live
When a creator adds Instagram's paid partnership label and you approve the tag, your business gets the post's insights directly, and loses them if the creator removes you from the label. Put this in the agreement so you are not relying on screenshots sent later.
A hypothetical comparison
A store that sells only in Saudi Arabia compares two accounts. The first has 300,000 followers, averages 6,000 views, and has 8% of its followers in Saudi Arabia. The second has 40,000 followers, averages 9,000 views, and has 70% of its followers in Saudi Arabia.
| Account | Average views | Audience in Saudi Arabia | Estimated viewers in your market |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | 6,000 | 8% | About 480 |
| Second | 9,000 | 70% | About 6,300 |
In this example the smaller account reaches far more of your potential customers. The estimate is rough, since viewers can sit in different countries from followers, but it is good enough to rank candidates.
Licensing and ad disclosure in Saudi Arabia and Egypt
In Saudi Arabia, a creator who advertises a product or service needs a Mawthooq licence. In Egypt we found no licence specific to influencer advertising as of our review date.
Saudi Arabia
According to Saudipedia's page on the Mawthooq licence, published in June 2023, the licence is mandatory for individuals advertising on social media for products or services offered in the Kingdom, and it falls under the General Authority for Media Regulation. Ads may only run from an account registered with the authority and linked to the licence, and not without a written contract or agreement. One exemption covers people promoting their own product or service from their personal account.
To verify, the authority and SDAIA launched a Mawthooq digital card in the Tawakkalna app in December 2024, with a QR code that confirms the licence is valid. Ask the creator to show the card, and check that the account they will post from is the one linked to it. Check the current terms on the General Authority for Media Regulation's website before you sign, as they can change. Hiring a non-Saudi creator raises further points, covered in our influencer marketing guide.
Egypt
We searched on 18 November 2026 and found no official rule requiring influencers to hold a licence before running ads. On 1 November 2026, Masrawy reported proposals that content creators put to the Minister of State for Media on regulating their work, including a professional body, so the framework is still under discussion.
What does apply is Consumer Protection Law No. 181 of 2018. Its Article 9 requires suppliers and advertisers to avoid deceptive conduct about a product's nature, characteristics and expected results. Your company is the advertiser here, so review what the creator will say about your product before it goes out.
Platform disclosure rules
Instagram's branded content policies require creators to use the branded content tool to tag the business partner, with that partner's consent. TikTok's branded content policy, effective 30 October 2026, requires creators to switch on the commercial content disclosure setting, which labels the video as branded content. Write disclosure into the agreement; a post that hides the ad also damages the audience's trust in you.
This is general information from public sources and is no substitute for legal advice. Review your contract with a lawyer in the country where you advertise.
Pre-contract checklist for any influencer
Copy this list, send it to every candidate, and ask for written answers before you discuss the fee:
- The top countries and cities screen for the last 30 days, and the share of the audience in your market.
- Average views on the last twelve posts, weak ones included.
- The follower growth chart for the last 90 days, with an explanation for any jump.
- Your own read of the comments on five posts, and how many ask about a product or service.
- Insights from at least two past sponsored posts, and what the creator knows about their results.
- Brands promoted in the last three months, so you know if your competitor is among them.
- In Saudi Arabia, the Mawthooq card in Tawakkalna and the account linked to it.
- Agreement to use Instagram's paid partnership label or TikTok's disclosure setting.
- Agreement to add your business as a partner on the post so its insights reach you directly.
- Number, type and dates of posts, and how long they stay up.
- Who approves content before it goes live, and how many rounds of edits are allowed.
- Your right to reuse the video in your ads and on your site, and for how long.
- A discount code and link unique to this creator, plus payment dates and invoice format.
If a creator refuses points one to five, the refusal tells you enough. Point thirteen is what ties a post to sales, so set it up with conversion measurement after the privacy changes before anything is published. If an agency hands you a list of influencers, ask it for the same points and apply the red flags when hiring a marketing agency.
Your next step
Pick three accounts from your shortlist today, send each one the screen recording request and points one to nine, and put the answers in one table with the estimated viewers in your market. Start with a single paid post with the strongest account before any longer package, and send it with a written brief built the way how to write an influencer brief that gets the content you want explains. If you want a team to handle the vetting, licensing, brief and measurement, that is the work of PlanKit's influencer marketing service.